INDIA: LEGAL WATCH
PANEL’S CLEAN CHIT TO CJI IS PREJUDICIAL TO THE RULE OF LAW
SUPREME COURT JUDGES HAVE BROKEN PUBLIC TRUST
2019-05-09 15:41
-
On May 6, the Panel of Judges appointed by Justice S.A. Bobde of the Supreme Court exonerated Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi of all allegations of sexual harassment levelled by an ex-employee of the Supreme Court and found ‘no substance’ in the woman’s complaint. The Committee comprised of Justice S.A. Bobde, Justice Indu Malhotra and Justice Indira Bannerjee, submitted its report to Supreme Court. However, astonishingly, the Committee did not give a copy of the report to the Complainant, citing an old case of Indira Jaising v. Supreme Court of India (2003) 5 SCC 494, wherein it was held that report of Committee constituted as part of the In-House Procedure, is not liable to be made public. But the same Committee thought it fit to give a copy of the report to the Chief Justice, against whom allegations of sexual harassment was made. Thus, curtains came down on the first part of the bizarre Kafkaesque drama that unfolded before the public in the last two weeks.