INDIA: CORPORATE WATCH
CENTRE IS CO-ACCUSED IN BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY
HOW DID UNION CARBIDE GET LICENCE?
2010-06-11 10:24
-
If anybody is to be blamed for the weak judicial magistrate court judgement in the 25-year-old Union Carbide case, it is the government of India and the charge-sheet filed by the Central Investigation Bureau (CBI). Judges do not act on emotions, passion or sentiment. They can only respond to specific charges on the basis on arguments and counter arguments by the prosecution and defence counsels. Their heads and hands are tied under the provisions of law. The Bhopal court had handed down the highest punishment to the offenders that could be served under the existing law. The offenders were merely charged with 'criminal negligence' by the prosecution and not 'culpable homicide not amounting to murder', which could have put the culprits behind the bars up to 10 years. Frankly, the case did not have much substance. 'Real culprits' were neither named, nor any effort made to involve them in the case.